Fed Keeps Rates Steady, But Signals More Cuts Coming in 2024

The Federal Reserve held its benchmark interest rate unchanged on Wednesday following its latest two-day policy meeting. However, the central bank signaled that multiple rate cuts are likely before the end of 2024 as it continues efforts to bring down stubbornly high inflation.

In its post-meeting statement, the Fed kept the target range for its federal funds rate at 5.25%-5.5%, where it has been since last July. This matched widespread expectations among investors and economists.

The more notable part of today’s announcements came from the Fed’s updated Summary of Economic Projections. The anonymous “dot plot” of individual policymaker expectations showed a median projection for three quarter-point rate cuts by year-end 2024.

This would mark a pivotal shift for the Fed, which has been steadily raising rates over the past year at the fastest pace since the 1980s to combat surging inflation. The last time the central bank cut rates was in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020.

Fed Chair Jerome Powell and other officials have signaled in recent months that softer policies could be appropriate once inflation shows further clear signs of moderating. Consumer prices remain elevated at 6% year-over-year as of February.

“While inflation has moderated somewhat since the middle of last year, it remains too high and further progress is needed,” said Powell in his post-meeting press conference. “We will remain data-dependent as we assess the appropriate stance of policy.”

The Fed’s updated economic projections now forecast GDP growth of 2.1% in 2024, up sharply from the 1.4% estimate in December. Core inflation is seen decelerating to 2.6% by year-end before returning to the Fed’s 2% target by 2026. The unemployment rate projection was nudged down to 4%.

With economic conditions still relatively strong, Powell stressed the central bank’s ability to move gradually and in a “risk management” mindset on raising or lowering interest rates. Markets expect the first rate cut to come as soon as June.

“The process of getting inflation down to 2% has a long way to go and is likely to be bumpy,” said Powell. “We have more work to do.”

The potential for rate cuts this year hinges on how quickly the lagging effects of the Fed’s aggressive tightening campaign over the past year feed through into lower price pressures. Policymakers will be closely watching metrics like consumer spending, wage growth, supply chains and inflation expectations for any signs that demand is cooling sustainably.

So far, the labor market has remained resilient, with job gains still robust and the unemployment rate hovering near 50-year lows around 3.5%. This tightness has allowed for solid wage gains, which risks perpetuating an inflationary price-wage spiral if not brought to heel.

While the road ahead remains highly uncertain, Powell stated that he feels the Fed has made enough policy adjustments already to at least pause the rate hiking cycle for now and switch into a data-driven risk management mode. This allows officials to be “patient” and avoid over-tightening while monitoring incoming information.

The Fed Chair also noted that discussions on reducing the central bank’s $8.4 trillion balance sheet began at this meeting, but no decisions have been made yet on adjusting the current runoff caps or pace.

In all, today’s Fed meeting reiterated the central bank’s intention to keep rates elevated for now while laying the groundwork for an eventual pivot to easier policy sometime later this year as disinflationary forces take deeper hold. Striking that balance between under and overtightening will be key for engineering a long-awaited soft landing for the economy.

Fed in No Rush to Cut Rates While Inflation Remains Elevated

The minutes from the Federal Reserve’s latest Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting reveal a cautious stance by policymakers toward lowering interest rates this year, despite growing evidence of cooling inflation. The minutes underscored the desire by Fed officials to see more definitive and sustainable proof that inflation is falling steadily back towards the Fed’s 2% target before they are ready to start cutting rates. This patient approach stands in contrast to market expectations earlier in 2024 that rate cuts could begin as soon as March.

The deliberations detailed in the minutes point to several key insights into the Fed’s current thinking. Officials noted they have likely finished raising the federal funds rate as part of the current tightening cycle, with the rate now in a range of 4.5-4.75% after starting 2022 near zero. However, they emphasized they are in no rush to start cutting rates, wanting greater confidence first that disinflation trends will persist. Members cited the risks of easing policy too quickly if inflation fails to keep slowing.

The minutes revealed Fed officials’ desire to cautiously assess upcoming inflation data to judge whether the recent downward trajectory is sustainable and not just driven by temporary factors. This patient approach comes despite recent encouraging reports of inflation slowing. The latest CPI and PPI reports actually came in above expectations, challenging hopes of more decisively decelerating price increases.

Officials also noted the economy remains resilient with a strong job market. This provides the ability to take a patient stance toward rate cuts rather than acting preemptively. How to manage the Fed’s $8 trillion balance sheet was also discussed, but details were light, with further debate expected at upcoming meetings.

Moreover, policymakers stressed ongoing unease over still elevated inflation and the harm it causes households, especially more vulnerable groups. This reinforced their cautious posture of needing solid evidence of controlled inflation before charting a policy shift.

In response to the minutes, markets have significantly pushed back expectations for the Fed’s rate cut timeline. Traders are now pricing in cuts starting in June rather than March, with the overall pace of 2024 cuts slowing. The minutes align with recent comments from Fed Chair Jerome Powell emphasizing the need for sustained proof that inflationary pressures are abating before rate reductions can begin.

The minutes highlight the tricky position the Fed faces in navigating policy uncertainty over how quickly inflation will decline even after aggressive 2023 rate hikes. Officials debated incoming data signals of potentially transitory inflation reductions versus risks of misjudging and overtightening policy. With the economy expanding solidly for now, the Fed has the leeway to be patient and avoid premature policy loosening. But further volatility in inflation readings could force difficult adjustments.

Looking ahead, markets will be hyper-focused on upcoming economic releases for evidence that could support a more decisive pivot in policy. Any signs of inflation slowing convincingly toward the Fed’s 2% goal could boost rate cut bets. Yet with labor markets and consumer demand still resilient, cooling inflation to the Fed’s satisfaction may take time. The minutes clearly signaled Fed officials will not be rushed into lowering rates until they are fully convinced price stability is sustainably taking hold. Their data-dependent approach points to a bumpy path ahead for markets.

Fed Holds Rates Steady, Cools Expectations for Imminent Cuts

The Federal Reserve left interest rates unchanged on Wednesday following its January policy meeting, keeping the federal funds rate target range at 5.25-5.50%, the highest level since 2007. The decision came as expected, but Fed Chair Jerome Powell pushed back on market bets of rate cuts potentially starting as soon as March.

In the post-meeting statement, the Fed removed language about needing additional policy tightening, signaling a likely prolonged pause in rate hikes as it assesses the impact of its aggressive actions over the past year. However, officials emphasized they do not foresee cuts on the horizon until inflation shows “greater progress” moving back to the 2% goal sustainably.

Powell Caution on Rate Cuts

During his press conference, Powell aimed to temper expectations that rate cuts could begin in just a couple months. He stated March is “probably not the most likely case” for the start of easing, rather the “base case” is the Fed holds rates steady for an extended period to confirm inflation is solidly on a downward trajectory.

Markets have been pricing in rate cuts in 2024 based on recent data showing inflation cooling from 40-year highs last year. But the Fed wants to avoid undoing its progress prematurely. Powell said the central bank would need more consistent evidence on inflation, not just a few months of decent data.

Still Room for Soft Landing

The tone indicates the Fed believes there is room for a soft landing where inflation declines closer to target without triggering a recession. Powell cited solid economic growth, a strong job market near 50-year low unemployment, and six straight months of easing price pressures.

While risks remain, the Fed views risks to its dual mandate as balancing out rather than tilted to the downside. As long as the labor market and consumer spending hold up, a hard landing with severe growth contraction may be avoided.

Markets Catching Up to Fed’s Thinking

Markets initially expected interest rate cuts to start in early 2024 after the Fed’s blistering pace of hikes over the past year. But officials have been consistent that they need to keep policy restrictive for some time to ensure inflation’s retreat is lasting.

After the latest guidance reiterating this view, traders adjusted expectations for the timing of cuts. Futures now show around a coin flip chance of a small 25 basis point rate cut at the March FOMC meeting, compared to up to a 70% chance priced in earlier.

Overall the Fed is making clear that investors are too optimistic on the imminence of policy easing. The bar to cutting rates remains high while the economy expands moderately and inflation readings continue improving.

Normalizing Policy Ahead

Looking beyond immediate rate moves, the Fed is focused on plotting a course back to more normal policy over time. This likely entails holding rates around the current elevated range for much of 2024 to solidify inflation’s descent.

Then later this year or early 2025, the beginnings of rate cuts could materialize if justified by the data. The dot plot forecast shows Fed officials pencil in taking rates down to 4.5-4.75% by year’s end.

But Powell was adamant that lowering rates is not yet on the table. The Fed will need a lengthy period of inflation at or very close to its 2% goal before definitively shifting to an easing cycle.

In the meantime, officials are content to pause after their historic tightening campaign while still keeping rates restrictive enough to maintain control over prices. As Powell made clear, investors anxiously awaiting rate cuts will likely need to keep waiting a bit longer.

Powell Hints at Potential for More Rate Hikes

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell doused investor hopes of a near-term pause in interest rate hikes, stating “we are not confident that we have achieved such a stance” that would allow inflation to drift down towards the Fed’s 2% target.

In remarks at an International Monetary Fund event, Powell said bringing inflation sustainably down to 2% still has “a long way to go”. His tone cast serious doubt on market expectations that the Fed is almost done raising rates in this cycle.

Traders have priced in a greater than 90% chance of just a 25 basis point December hike, followed by rate cuts commencing in mid-2023. But Powell stressed the Fed stands ready to tighten policy further if economic conditions warrant.

Powell acknowledged recent positive developments, including moderating inflation readings, strong GDP growth, and improvements in supply chains. However, he noted it is unclear how much more progress supply-side factors can drive.

That puts the onus on the Fed to ensure slowing demand prevents inflation from reaccelerating. Powell made clear the Fed will stay the course, even if that means defying market hopes for a dovish pivot.

How High Could Rates Go?

Markets are currently priced for Fed Funds to peak under 5% after a quarter point December increase. But Powell’s insistence on not letting up prematurely raises the specter of a higher terminal rate.

If strong economic reports continue showing robust consumer spending and tight labor markets, the Fed may opt for 50 basis points in December. That would leave rates squarely in the 5-5.25% range, with more hikes possible in early 2023 if inflation persists.

Powell was adamant the Fed cannot be swayed by a few months of data, given the fickle nature of inflation. Premature rate cuts could allow inflation to become re-entrenched, requiring even more aggressive hikes down the road.

With Powell determined to avoid that scenario, investors may need to brace for interest rates cresting above current expectations before the Fed finally stops tightening.

Growth and Jobs Still Too Hot?

Behind Powell’s hawkish messaging is a still-hot economy that could be fueling inflation pressures beneath the surface. The U.S. unemployment rate remains near 50-year lows at 3.7%, with job openings still far exceeding available workers.

Meanwhile, GDP growth rebounded to a strong 2.6% rate in the third quarter, defying recession predictions. Consumer spending has remained remarkably resilient as well.

Powell recognizes the Fed may need to cool economic activity more meaningfully to align demand with constrained supply. That explains his lack of confidence on inflation without further rate increases.

Markets move lower after Powell cools pivot hopes

Stock indexes immediately turned lower following Powell’s remarks, with the Dow shedding around 200 points. Treasury yields also spiked as expectations for longer-term Fed hikes intensified.

Powell succeeded in resetting market assumptions, making clear the Fed has no intentions of reversing course anytime soon just because inflation has shown initial signs of improvement.

Until policymakers have high confidence lasting 2% inflation is in sight, Powell indicated the Fed’s tightening campaign will continue. That may disappoint stock and bond investors banking on rate cuts next year, but fighting inflation remains Powell’s top priority.

With the Fed Chair throwing cold water on pivot hopes, markets will likely undergo a reassessment of just how high the Fed may yet raise rates. Powell’s tone hints investors should brace for more tightening ahead, even if that delays the desired easing cycle.

Don’t Fear the Rate Hike

Image Credit: Samer Daboul (Pexels)

Historically, Tightening Cycles Have Not Caused Long-Lasting Market Damage

The Fed does not plan on having a tight monetary policy, just a less easy one.

On March 16, 2022, the FOMC Committee announced their intention to target a fed funds rate that would be 0.25% higher than it had been. It was the first increase since December 2018, and the hike more than doubled this key interest rate. Fed Chair Powell made it clear it would not be the Committee’s last.

Less than two months later, on May 4, the Fed adjusted the overnight target by an additional 0.50%. This was the largest increase since the year 2000.   But they were just getting started. They suspected they had fallen behind in their mandate of keeping inflation down. Stable prices generally mean balancing supply and demand, and since the Fed couldn’t do much to raise the consumable supply, they acted to dampen demand. They made money more expensive. In mid-June, the Fed hiked by 0.75%, in late July it pushed them up by 0.75% again, and that was the last time the FOMC met.

The next meeting will be held September 20-21st. The perceived guidance is that they will raise rates again by a similar amount as they did in June and July.

Tightening Cycles

The current tightening cycle is a concern for those that fear that it may lower asset prices and lower business activity. The concerns are warranted as tightening cycles are designed to do exactly that, tame prices and slow economic growth. It’s tough medicine but is supposed to provide for better economic health long term.

Over the past 30 years, the Fed has convened four recognized tightening cycles – periods when it increased the federal funds rate multiple times.

Source: Federal Reserve

Over three decades, the median number of rate hikes per period is eight, and the median time frame is 18 months (from first to last). How has the economy and markets fared through this recent history? Only two of the periods, the one ending in 2000 and then in 2006, were associated with a recession. In all four cases, the market retreated at first.

If one uses GDP as a measuring stick for an economy that is either growing or receding, then the U.S. was in a recessionary economy for a calendar quarter before the initial 0.25% hike. So the tightening may not put us into a recession, but it does have the potential to retard growth further for a  deeper recession.

Market Performance

Markets have traded lower in the months following the start of a tightening cycle, but in each of the periods defined above, they have ended higher one year later. It would seem that the market fear of what slower growth would do for companies and stock prices were front-loaded; those fears then gave way to buying as expectations became better defined.

Source: Koyfin

For the tightening cycle that began in 1994, a year after the Fed first took aim at the economy, the S&P 500 Index had already bounced off its low and climbed rapidly to end the 12 months with a positive 2.41% return. At it’s worst, the index had given up 6.50%.

Source: Koyfin

Four months after the tightening cycle began in 1999, the market began marching higher and crossed the breakeven point three times. The first time in August, just 45 days into the cycle, and the last one in May of 2000. For the 12-month period an investor in the index would have gained 5.97%.

Source: Koyfin

In 2004 the tightening cycle again began on June 30. Stock movement over the 12 months that followed are very similar as 1999. For investors that held for five months, (assuming their holdings approximated this benchmark) they were treated with returns of 4.43% 12 months later.    

Source: Koyfin

The most recent tightening cycle was seven years ago and began in December. Those invested in securities in 2015 that followed the overall stock market quickly broke even, and for those that held, they were up 10.81% a year later.

On average over the four periods the S&P 500 returned better than 6% after the Fed began a prolonged tightening cycle. The median drawdown is observed to be 9% in the first 49 days following the Fed’s first rate hike. For those that were invested in stocks that were more closely correlated to other indices, their experience was different.

Other Indices (Small Cap, Value, Growth)

Source: Bloomberg

The best average, although it did have a negative return in one of the periods, is the performance of the small cap Russell 2000 index. Investors in small cap stocks would have earned almost twice as much (11.30%) as those invested in the S&P 500 Large cap, almost three times as much earnings as those invested in the Russell 1000 Value stocks, and far more consistent and more than three times the Russell 1000 Growth index.

Take Away

This is not the first time the Federal Reserve has raised rates and implemented a tighter monetary policy. In the past it has not meant doom for the economy. In fact, the policy shift is intended to preserve a healthy economy before it begins causing larger problems for those that depend on jobs and stable prices along with a orderly banking system.

The most recent tightening cycle began six months ago. If history is an indicator, it may last another year, during that time stocks will rebound to a level higher than they were in March when the cycle began. While there are no guarantees that history will accurately point to the future, it helps to know what happened the last four times. Investors may also look to increase their allocation into small cap stocks as they have by far outpaced other indices.

Paul Hoffman

Managing Editor, Channelchek

Sources

https://www.federalreserve.gov/datadownload/Choose.aspx?rel=PRATES

https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/fed-funds-rate-history/

https://www.putnam.com/advisor/content/perspectives/