Inflation in the United States showed alarmingly little signs of cooling in March, according to the latest data on the Federal Reserve’s preferred price gauge released Friday. The stubbornly elevated readings essentially guarantee the U.S. central bank will need to keep interest rates higher for longer to fully constrain persistent price pressures.
The core personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, which strips out volatile food and energy costs, rose 2.8% in March from a year earlier, the Commerce Department reported. This matched February’s annual increase and exceeded economists’ expectations of 2.7%.
On a month-over-month basis, the core PCE climbed 0.3% in March, in line with projections. The headline PCE price index including food and energy costs also rose 0.3% for the month and was up 2.7% annually.
The data highlights the challenges the Fed is facing in its battle to bring inflation back down to its 2% target after it surged to multi-decade highs last year on supply shocks, robust demand and pandemic-driven disruptions. Price pressures have proved remarkably persistent, defying the central bank’s aggressive interest rate hiking campaign that kicked off in March 2022.
“Inflation reports released this morning were not as hot as feared, but investors should not get overly anchored to the idea that inflation has been completely cured and the Fed will be cutting interest rates in the near-term,” said George Mateyo, chief investment officer at Key Private Bank. “The prospects of rate cuts remain, but they are not assured.”
The fresh PCE readings follow worse-than-expected inflation figures in Thursday’s GDP report that revealed the personal consumption expenditures price index surged at a 3.4% annualized rate in the first quarter. That was well above the 2.7% forecast and offset a decent 1.6% rise in economic growth over the same period.
The persistent inflation pressures backed bets that the Fed will likely leave interest rates unchanged at the current 4.75%-5% range at its next couple of meetings in June and July. According to the CME Group’s FedWatch tool, traders now see around a 44% probability that the central bank could implement two quarter-point rate cuts by the end of 2023.
However, most analysts agree that the Fed would need to see clear signs that consistently high inflation is beginning to dent the still-robust labor market before feeling confident about pivoting to an easing cycle. Policymakers want to avoid making the same mistake of prematurely loosening monetary policy like they did in the 1970s, which allowed inflation to become deeply entrenched.
For investors, the path forward for markets hinges on whether the Fed can achieve a so-called “soft landing” by getting inflation under control without sparking a severe recession. Equity traders largely looked past Friday’s inflation data, with futures pointing to a higher open on Wall Street. But Treasury yields edged lower as traders increased bets on the Fed ultimately reversing course next year.
Still, the latest PCE figures underscore the Fed’s dilemma and the likelihood that interest rates will need to remain restrictive for some time to prevent inflation from becoming unmoored. That raises the risks of overtightening and potential economic turbulence ahead as the full impact of the most aggressive tightening cycle since the 1980s hits home.
The Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index rose 0.4% in January from the previous month, notching its largest monthly gain since January 2023, according to data released by the Commerce Department on Thursday. On an annual basis, headline PCE inflation, which includes volatile food and energy categories, slowed to 2.4% from 2.6% in December.
More importantly, the Federal Reserve’s preferred core PCE inflation gauge, which excludes food and energy, increased 0.4% month-over-month and 2.8% year-over-year. The 2.8% annual increase was the slowest since March 2021 and matched analyst estimates. However, the monthly pop indicates inflation may be bottoming out after two straight months of cooling.
The data presents a mixed picture for the Federal Reserve as it fights to lower inflation back to its 2% target. On one hand, the slowing annual inflation rate shows the cumulative effect of the Fed’s aggressive interest rate hikes in 2022. This supports the case for ending the hiking cycle soon and potentially cutting rates later this year if the trend continues.
On the other hand, the sharp monthly increase in January shows inflation is not yet on a clear downward trajectory. Some components of the PCE report also flashed warning signs. Services inflation excluding energy picked up while goods disinflation moderated. This could reflect the tight labor market and pent-up services demand.
Markets are currently pricing in around a 40% chance of a rate cut in June. But with inflation showing signs of stabilizing in January, the Fed will likely want to see a more definitive downward trend before changing course. Central bank officials have repeatedly emphasized they need to see “substantially more evidence” that inflation is falling before pausing or loosening policy.
The latest PCE data will unlikely satisfy that threshold. As a result, markets now see almost no chance of a rate cut at the March Fed meeting and still expect at least one more 25 basis point hike to the fed funds target range.
The January monthly pop in inflation will make Fed officials more cautious about declaring victory too soon or pivoting prematurely to rate cuts. But the slowing annual trend remains intact for now. As long as that continues, the Fed could shift to data-dependent mode later this year and consider rate cuts if other economic barometers, like employment, soften.
For consumers and businesses, the inflation outlook remains murky in the near-term but with some positive signs on the horizon. Overall price increases are gradually cooling from their peaks but could plateau at moderately high levels in the first half of 2024 based on January’s data.
Households will get temporary relief at the gas pump as energy inflation keeps slowing. But they will continue facing higher rents, medical care costs, and services prices amid strong demand and tight labor markets. Supply chain difficulties and China’s reopening could also re-accelerate some goods inflation.
Still, the Fed’s sustained monetary policy tightening should help rebalance demand and supply over time. As rate hikes compound and growth slows, inflationary pressures should continue easing. But consumers and businesses cannot expect rapid deflation or a return to the low inflation regime of the past decade anytime soon.
For the FOMC, the January data signals a need to hold steady at the upcoming March meeting and remain patient through the first half of 2024. Jumping straight to rate cuts risks repeating the mistake of the 1970s by loosening too soon. Officials have to let the delayed effects of tightening play out further.
With inflation showing early tentative signs of plateauing, the Fed is likely on hold for at least a few more meetings. But if price increases continue declining back toward 2% later this year, then small rate cuts can be back on the table. For now, the January data highlights the bumpy road back to price stability.
New government data released Thursday indicates that inflation ticked slightly higher in October but remained on a broader cooling trajectory as price pressures continue moderating from 40-year highs reached earlier this year. The report provides further evidence that the rapid pace of price increases may be starting to steadily decelerate, supporting the Federal Reserve’s recent inclination to halt its aggressive interest rate hike campaign.
The Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, the core personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, rose 0.2% last month and 3.5% over the past year. This matched consensus economist forecasts. The core PCE index strips out volatile food and energy costs to provide a clearer view underlying price trends.
While still well above the Fed’s 2% target, the annual increase was down from 5.3% in February. The incremental monthly gain showed prices climbing at a more restrained pace after an intense burst earlier this year.
“The Fed is on hold for now but their pivot to rate cuts is getting closer,” said Bill Adams, chief economist at Comerica Bank. “Inflation is clearly slowing.”
Markets are already betting policymakers won’t hike rates again this cycle, and may even start cutting in 2024 to bolster growth as price pressures continue easing. The latest data provides credibility to the idea that the Fed’s rapid rate hikes since March, which have raised its benchmark to a 15-year high, have begun achieving their intended effect of reining in demand and cooling the economy enough to tame inflation back toward manageable levels.
Still Cautious on Further Easing
However, Fed officials stressed that rates will still need to remain at restrictive levels for some time to ensure inflation continues descending toward the central bank’s 2% target.
New York Fed President John Williams said Thursday he expects inflation to keep drifting lower, finally hitting the Fed’s goal by 2025. But he emphasized rates will likely need to stay elevated until then to completely quell price pressures.
Other Fed policymakers also struck a cautious tone on prematurely ending rate hikes before inflation is convincingly on a path back towards the 2% goal. Many noted that while price increases may be peaking, inflation remains stubbornly high and consumer demand continues holding up more than feared despite rapid rate rises this year.
Moderating Labor Market Could Allow Rate Cuts
There were some early signs in Thursday’s data that the torrid job market may also finally be cooling slightly after persisting at unsustainable levels through much of the year.
The report showed continuing jobless claims climbed to 1.93 million in mid-November, their highest mark since November 2021. The number of Americans applying for ongoing unemployment benefits has risen by more than 80,000 since October.
While still historically low, the increase could provide Fed officials confidence that their rate hikes have begun not only slowing demand and price growth, but also easing excessively tight labor market conditions they have said contributed to rapid wage and inflation surges.
An easing job market that reduces wage pressures could give the Fed leeway next year to shift their priority toward sustaining growth and cut rates to spur a slowing economy, especially as other inflationary pressures subside.
Consumers Keeping Pace For Now
On the growth side, the report showed some signs of resilience among consumers even in the face of elevated inflation and rising borrowing costs.
Personal income and consumer spending both edged up 0.2% in October, indicating households are so far keeping pace with rising prices digging into their paychecks. Services like travel and healthcare saw particularly solid spending last month.
Surveys show consumers remain relatively upbeat thanks to still-ample savings and solid income growth. But many Fed officials have noted anecdotally that households appear to be pulling back spending more than aggregate data indicates so far. Any sharper-than-expected deceleration in consumer demand would give policymakers leeway to pivot toward supporting growth.
Eyes on Services Inflation
Some economists noted that while goods prices have cooled sharply from peaks last year amid improving supply issues, services costs remain stubbornly high for now as resilience in consumer demand combined with rising wage growth enables firms to pass higher labor expenses to customers.
“Inflation is moderating with goods prices leading the charge,” said economist Nancy Vanden Houten of Oxford Economics. But she said core services costs actually ticked up in October, bearing monitoring to ensure price stability as the economy shifts more toward services consumption over goods.
With strong income gains and accumulated savings still underpinning spending for now, officials emphasized rates may need to stay higher for longer to ensure the progress made on easing price pressures sticks.
“I expect it will be appropriate to maintain a restrictive stance for quite some me to fully restore balance and to bring inflation back to our 2 percent longer-run goal on a sustained basis,” said the New York Fed’s Williams on Thursday.
Today’s news brings the release of the August data for the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) Index by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis. This report, a crucial indicator of inflation and consumer spending in the United States, has set a positive tone for financial markets as they rally in early trading.
In August, the PCE Index recorded a year-over-year growth rate of 3.5%, showing a modest increase from the previous month’s 3.4%. On a monthly basis, the core PCE, the Federal Reserve’s preferred measure of inflation, inched up by 0.1%, slightly lower than the 0.2% increase in July.
The Federal Reserve has long regarded the core PCE as its favored measure of inflation. While the August PCE report has provided insight into inflation trends, it’s important to note that the Fed made a decision to keep interest rates steady earlier this week. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell consistently references the core PCE figures when assessing inflation. Powell has emphasized that inflation remains above the Fed’s 2% target, which has informed the central bank’s recent decision to maintain interest rates within a range of 5.25%-5.50%. This decision underscores the Fed’s cautious approach to managing inflation while fostering economic growth.
Historically, PCE reports have played a significant role in guiding monetary policy and influencing market dynamics. When inflationary pressures rise, the Fed may respond by raising interest rates to curb price increases. Conversely, when PCE growth moderates, the central bank may opt for rate cuts to stimulate economic activity.
While the report suggests a slower pace of inflation growth in August compared to July, inflation remains a pertinent issue. Investors will closely monitor subsequent reports and Federal Reserve actions to gain insight into the trajectory of inflation and its potential impact on financial markets and the broader economy. The early market rally reflects the market’s optimism following the release of the latest PCE data, as it continues to navigate the evolving economic landscape.
The Increasing Popularity of the PCE Inflation Gauge
US inflation, by a number of official measures, reached its highest level in 40 years last year. For a large percentage of investors and shoppers, this is their first experience of prices quickly rising. For decades, on many tech products, prices declined over time (while adding functionality). There are a number of different measures of inflation reported regularly – they impact us in different ways. Knowing the difference, whether you’re investing, planning a purchase, or expecting a cost of living (COLA) increase, is helpful. Below we go through the different measures so you understand the impact of say “headline CPI” versus “core PCE.”
According to James Bullard, the president and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, “measuring inflation is one of the most difficult issues studied by economists.”
By definition, inflation is the percentage change in overall prices in the economy over a specified period, commonly quoted as a year-over-year change. It’s much more than an increase in the prices of a few products. Given the inherent difficulties in following every price in the country, economists have created price indexes to approximate the overall price level.
PCE Inflation
Before the year 2000, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) primarily focused on the Consumer Price Index (CPI) as its inflation gauge. We’ll explain CPI next, but for the Fed, when it now says it has a 2% inflation target, PCE is the data used.
Though the two indexes have a lot of overlap, there are reasons why the PCE is considered a better tool by policymakers.
The PCE price index, which rose 5.5% in November 2022 from a year earlier, is derived from a broader index of prices than the CPI’s more narrow set of goods and services. The argument as to why policymakers gave an edge in the late 1990s to make the change in 2000 is that a more comprehensive index (such as PCE) of prices provides a better way to gauge underlying inflationary pressures. Since the PCE includes more goods and services, the index’s weights for particular items will differ dramatically from those in the CPI. For example, housing has a weight of about 16% in the PCE price index versus 33% in the CPI. The varied items more accurately reflect actual costs to consumers since they may substitute one for another as prices of items change at different rates. This ability to substitute is a primary reason why PCE tends to print lower than headline CPI.
CPI Remains Important
The most widely cited measure of inflation is the headline Consumer Price Index (CPI), which is calculated by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). This index was created in 1919 as officials devised a way to measure rising consumer prices just after World War I.
The CPI, which rose 6.5% for all of 2022, measures the price changes for a basket of goods and services purchased by the typical urban consumer. The items in this basket are weighted by their relative importance in consumer expenditures. For example, housing—rent and other spending on shelter—accounts for 33% of the index, while medical care accounts for nearly 9%.
This index, like others, takes into account changing consumption. New items come in and old items leave. The example I like to use is that prohibition began in January 1920, just after CPI came into use. Alcohol was not part of the index back then, whereas it is today (5.78% increase in 2022), product adoption changes.
The CPI weights had been adjusted every two years using two years of consumer spending data. Starting in 2023, the BLS will update weights annually using one year of data.
Headline PCE Inflation versus Headline CPI Inflation
The increasing popularity of the PCE is because the index’s weights are updated monthly, versus annually for CPI (prior to 2023 updates were every two years). Thus, the PCE can quickly reflect the impact of new technology or an abrupt change in consumer spending patterns. For example, the onset of the coronavirus pandemic quickly shifted consumption from services like restaurants to services like communication technology. Since the headline PCE uses more timely, actual outlays, it provides the FOMC a more accurate consumer experience in terms of inflation.
The stated target by the FOMC is 2%, a level that policymakers judge to be consistent with achieving price stability and maximum employment. On average, inflation was hovering below this target before the pandemic’s economic ramifications (from 1995 through 2019 PCE average equaled 1.8%).
Other Inflation Measures
While the FOMC targets headline PCE inflation, policymakers also watch other measures to gauge inflationary pressures. The headline PCE measure can be quite volatile due to the effects of extreme price movements for certain products. To get a sense of where underlying inflation really is, economists often look at some summary measure of inflation that doesn’t include these volatile prices.
A so-called “core” index—whether it be PCE or CPI—excludes food and energy components. That has some simplicity around it, but it’s not satisfactory. There are better ways to analyze underlying inflation than to throw out certain goods and services, especially those that hit low- to moderate-income consumers the hardest when prices rise. And even if you exclude food and energy prices, the remaining part of the index is still affected by their volatility; restaurant prices would be a classic example.
More recently, other statistical ideas have been developed. One method looks at price change distribution for the entire range of goods and services.3
One commonly used measure of this type is the Dallas Fed trimmed-mean PCE inflation rate, which removes the upper tail (the largest price changes) and the lower tail (the smallest price changes) and then takes a weighted average of the price changes for the remaining components. This measure has been popular as a tool for examining trends and overall inflation as opposed to special factors that might be driving inflation. Of course, these types of measures4 tend to be more persistent and move more slowly than headline inflation measures.
Take Away
While market concerns over inflation for many years were low and most may have been more concerned about deflation, the current tight supply of goods and labor, coupled with the easiness of money, has ushered in a period where markets are likely to feel the impact of each inflation post.
Understanding the most watched inflation gauges will help sort out whether a trend or single post is likely to cause a change in course on interest rates. Or is it more likely a blip that will on average work its way out? The Fed is currently targeting a PCE inflation rate of 2%. The current pace is more than double this, but trending down after the Fed tightened in 2022 at a record pace. The Fed and the markets are now awaiting the impact of those cuts as there is a lag in applying the economic brakes (to lessen inflation) and when the economy has its biggest reaction to the Fed’s heavy pressure on the brake pedal.
