Job Market Stays Resilient as Openings Hold Steady

The latest employment data shows the resilience of the US labor market, even as the Federal Reserve remains locked in an inflation battle. The number of job openings across the country was essentially unchanged in February at 8.76 million, according to the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) released by the Labor Department.

While just a slight 0.1% uptick from January’s revised 8.75 million openings, the figure highlights how robust hiring demand remains from employers over a year into the Fed’s interest rate hiking campaign. Job vacancies have been sticky at extremely elevated levels, leaving Fed officials frustrated in their efforts to ease wage growth and inflationary pressures.

“The labor market continues to defy expectations of a meaningful cooling,” said Samantha Gunther, economist at Credence Economics. “With openings still so high, wage growth is likely to remain too strong for the Fed’s liking in the months ahead.”

The JOLTS data precedes this week’s highly anticipated March jobs report, which is forecast to show nonfarm payrolls increased by 230,000 positions. That would mark a fourth straight month of job gains over 200,000, underscoring the employment market’s enduring tightness.

There were some modest signs of a gradual loosening in labor conditions buried within February’s openings figures. Job vacancies fell in sectors like information, healthcare and retail trade. More notably, the overall level of layoffs jumped to 1.8 million, the highest since last April, led by a spike in the leisure and hospitality industry.

“While the bar remains high for calling a turn in the labor cycle, we’re seeing some initial hints of cracks starting to form,” said Ryan Bingham, lead labor economist at ADP. “Higher borrowing costs are clearly starting to bite for certain service-sector businesses.”

The report also showed rates of workers quitting their jobs to pursue other opportunities held steady at 2.2% in February, the lowest since the summer of 2020. The diminished quits rate could indicate employees are feeling less confident about switching roles in a more uncertain economic climate.

Another indicator pointing to some easing was the ratio of available workers to job openings, which slipped to 1.36 from 1.43 in January. While still a very tight ratio favoring employers over job seekers, it marked progress toward better balance after peaking above 2-to-1 last year.

For the Fed, the upshot is likely more patience in leaving interest rates elevated. Chair Jerome Powell reiterated last week that stronger labor market “gives” would be needed to bring down unacceptably high inflation back toward the 2% goal.

With payroll growth expected to remain solid and job openings still extremely elevated, it will take more time before productivity-enhancing labor slack emerges. The latest JOLTS figures suggest that process is underway, however gradual it may prove to be.

Treasury Yields Jump Ahead of Crucial Economic Data and Powell Testimony

U.S. Treasury yields kicked off the new week on an upswing as investors braced for a slew of high-impact economic releases and testimony from Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell that could shape the central bank’s monetary policy path. With inflation still running high and the labor market remaining resilient, all eyes are on the incoming data to gauge whether the Fed’s aggressive rate hikes have begun cooling economic activity enough to potentially allow a pause or pivot.

The yield on the 10-year Treasury note, a benchmark for mortgage rates and other consumer lending products, rose by around 4 basis points to 4.229% on Monday. The 2-year yield, which is highly sensitive to Fed policy expectations, spiked over 5 basis points higher to 4.585%. Yields rise when bond prices fall as investors demand higher returns to compensate for inflation risks.

The move in yields came ahead of a data-heavy week packed with labor market indicators that could influence whether the Fed continues hiking rates or signals a prolonged pause is forthcoming. Investors have been hanging on every new economic report in hopes of clarity on when the central bank’s tightening cycle may finally conclude.

“The labor market remains the key variable for Fed policy, so any upside surprises on that front will likely be interpreted as raising the prospect of further rate hikes,” said Kathy Bostjancic, chief U.S. economist at Oxford Economics. “Conversely, signs of cooling could open the door to rate hikes ending soon and discussion over rate cuts later this year.”

This week’s labor market highlights include the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) for January on Wednesday, ADP’s monthly private payrolls report on Thursday, and the ever-important nonfarm payrolls data for February on Friday. Economists project the economy added 205,000 jobs last month, according to Refinitiv estimates, down from January’s blockbuster 517,000 gain but still a solid pace of hiring.

Beyond employment, investors will also scrutinize fresh insights from Fed Chair Powell when he delivers his semi-annual monetary policy testimony to Congress on Wednesday and Thursday. Any signals Powell sends about upcoming rate decisions and the central bank’s perspective on achieving price stability could spark volatility across markets.

“Given how uncertain the path is regarding where rates will peak and how long they’ll remain at that level, markets will be hyper-focused on Powell’s latest take,” DataTrek co-founder Nick Colas commented. “Right now, futures are pricing in one more 25 basis point hike at the March meeting followed by a pause, but that could certainly change depending on Powell’s tone this week.”

Interest rates in the fed funds futures market are currently implying a 70% probability the Fed raises its benchmark rate by a quarter percentage point later this month to a target range of 4.75%-5.00%. However, projections for where rates peak remain widely dispersed, ranging from 5.00%-5.25% on the dovish end up to 5.50%-5.75% at the hawkish extreme if inflationary forces persist.

Central to the Fed’s calculus is progress on its dual mandate of achieving maximum employment and price stability. While the labor market has remained extraordinarily tight, the latest inflation data has sent mixed signals, muddling the policy outlook.

In January, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge – the personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index – showed an annual increase of 5.4% for the headline figure and 4.7% for the core measure that strips out volatile food and energy costs. While still well above the 2% target, the year-over-year readings decelerated from December, potentially marking a peak for this cycle.

However, other data including the consumer price index and producer prices have painted a stickier inflation picture. Rapidly rising services costs, stubbornly high rents, and short-term inflation expectations ticking higher have all fueled anxiety that the disinflationary process isn’t playing out as smoothly as hoped.

Complicating matters is the impact of higher rates for longer on economic growth and the broader financial system. Last week’s reports of Silicon Valley Bank and Silvergate Capital making severe business cuts crystallized the double-edged sword of tighter monetary policy. While intended to cool demand and thwart inflation, rising borrowing costs can tip the scale towards financial stress.

Given these cross-currents, all eyes will be fixated on this week’s dataflow and Powell’s latest rhetoric. Softer labor market figures and more affirmation inflation is peaking could pave the way for an extended pause in rate hikes later this year. But a continued barrage of hot data and rising inflation expectations could embolden the Fed to deliver additional super-sized rate increases to fortify its inflation-fighting credibility, even at the risk of raising recession risks. Market participants should brace for a pivotal week ahead.

JOLTS Report Shows Ongoing Labor Market Tightness

The latest Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) report released Tuesday by the Bureau of Labor Statistics showed job openings rose to 9.02 million in December, up from a revised 8.92 million in November. This was higher than economist forecasts of 8.75 million openings.

The December JOLTS report indicates ongoing tightness in the US labor market, as job openings remain stubbornly high even as the Federal Reserve has aggressively raised interest rates over the past year to cool demand and curb inflationary pressures.

On the surface, the rise in openings appears a negative sign for monetary policy aimed at loosening the jobs market. However, the increase was small, and openings remain well below the March 2023 peak of 11.9 million. The quits rate, which measures voluntary departures and is an indicator of workers’ confidence in ability to find new jobs, also edged down to 2.1% in December, though it remains elevated historically.

This suggests the Fed’s policy actions may be having a gradual effect, but the labor market remains tight overall. Layoffs also stayed low in December, with just 1.6 million separations due to layoffs or discharges during the month. The labor force participation rate ticked up to 62.3% in December, so labor supply is expanding somewhat, though participation remains below pre-pandemic levels.

For the Fed, the report provides ammunition on both sides of the debate as to whether a pause in rate hikes is warranted or further increases are needed to achieve a soft landing. Markets see a mixed bag, with the US dollar index largely unchanged on the day and Treasury yields seeing only slight moves following the release.

Impact on Economic Outlook

The bigger picture is that while job openings are declining, they remain unusually high, indicative of continued broad demand for workers across sectors like healthcare, manufacturing, and hospitality. Businesses appear eager to hire even amidst an economic slowdown and uncertainty about the outlook.

This need for workers will support consumer spending, the primary engine of US GDP growth, as long as hiring remains robust and layoffs low. But it also means upward pressure on wages as employers compete for talent, which could fuel inflation. Herein lies the conundrum for monetary policy.

The strength of the labor market is a double-edged sword – positive for growth in the near term, but concerning for the Fed’s inflation fight if it necessitates further large wage increases.

Chair Powell has been adamant the Fed’s priority is reducing inflation, even at the risk of economic pain. With the jobs market still hot in late 2023, further rate hikes seem likely at upcoming policy meetings absent a substantial cooling in inflation or rise in unemployment.

Payroll growth could slow in 2024 from levels above 400,000 per month in 2023, but demand remains too high relative to labor supply. The Fed wants meaningful softening in job openings and wage growth, which has yet to fully materialize. Unemployment would likely need to rise to the high 3% range or beyond to reduce wage pressures.

The JOLTS report provides important context on the state of the labor market amid crosscurrents in other economic data. Manufacturing has slowed and housing has declined, but consumers keep spending and job switching remains high. The Fed is unlikely to declare victory or shift to rate cuts with this conflicting mix of weak and resilient activity.

The path for monetary policy and markets will depend on which direction the trends in openings, wages, inflation and jobs growth tilt in coming months. For now, the JOLTS report gives the sense of an economy and labor market that are cooling gradually under the weight of higher rates rather than slowing precipitously.

Job Openings Dip but Labor Market Remains Strong

The monthly Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) report released this week showed job openings decreased slightly to 8.79 million in November. While a decline from October’s total, openings remain historically high, indicating continued labor market strength.

For investors, the data provides evidence that the economy is headed for a soft landing. The Federal Reserve aims to cool inflation by moderating demand and employment growth, without severely damaging the job market. The modest dip in openings suggests its interest rate hikes are having the intended effect.

Openings peaked at 11.9 million in March 2022 as employers struggled to fill vacancies in the tight post-pandemic job market. The ratio of openings to unemployed workers hit nearly 2-to-1. This intense competition for workers drove up wages, contributing to rampant inflation.

Since then, the Fed has rapidly increased borrowing costs to rein in spending and hiring. As a result, job openings have fallen over 25% from peak levels. In November, there were 1.4 openings for every unemployed person, down from 2-to-1 earlier this year.

While hiring also moderated in November, layoffs remained low. This indicates companies are being selective in their hiring rather than resorting to widespread job cuts. Employers added 263,000 jobs in November, underscoring labor market resilience.

With job openings still elevated historically and unemployment at 3.7%, the leverage remains on the side of workers in wage negotiations. But the cooling demand takes pressure off employers to fill roles at any cost.

Markets Welcome Gradual Slowdown

Financial markets have reacted positively to signs of a controlled economic deceleration. Stocks rallied in 2023 amid evidence that inflation was peaking while the job market avoided a precipitous decline.

Moderating job openings support the case for a soft landing. Investors hope further gradual cooling in labor demand will help the Fed tame inflation without triggering a severe downturn.

This optimizes the backdrop for corporate earnings. While companies face margin pressure from elevated wages and input costs, strong consumer spending power has mitigated the impact on revenues so far.

The risk is that the Fed overtightens and causes an excessive pullback in hiring. Another JOLTS report showing a sharper decline in openings would sound alarm bells. But November’s modest drop eases fears.

All eyes are now on the timing of the Fed’s anticipated pivot to interest rate cuts. Markets hope easing begins in mid-2024, while the Fed projects cuts starting later this year. The path of job openings will influence its timeline.

Slower but sustained labor demand enables the central bank to maintain a steady policy course. But an abrupt downward turn would pressure quicker rate cuts to stabilize growth.

Sector Impacts

The cooling job market has varying implications across stock market sectors. Rate-sensitive high-growth firms like technology would benefit most from earlier Fed easing.

Cyclical sectors closely tied to economic growth, like industrials and materials, favor the steady flight path as it sustains activity while containing inflation. Financials also prefer the status quo for now, given the tailwind of higher interest rates.

Meanwhile, sectors struggling with worker shortages and wage pressures welcome moderating openings. Leisure and hospitality saw one of the steepest monthly declines in November after leading last year’s hiring surge.

But the pullback remains measured rather than extreme. This supports a soft landing that preserves economic momentum and corporate earnings strength, even as financial conditions tighten. With the Fed striking a delicate balance so far, investors’ hopes are high for an extended expansion.