Consumer Spending Surge: Fed’s Rate Cut Hopes Face Economic Resilience

Key Points:
– U.S. consumer spending increased 0.5% in July, showing economic strength
– Inflation remains moderate, with PCE price index rising 2.5% year-on-year
– Robust spending challenges expectations for aggressive Fed rate cuts

In a surprising turn of events, U.S. consumer spending showed remarkable strength in July, potentially altering the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy trajectory. This robust economic indicator may put a damper on expectations for aggressive interest rate cuts, particularly the anticipated half-percentage-point reduction in September.

Consumer spending, which accounts for over two-thirds of U.S. economic activity, rose by 0.5% in July, following a 0.3% increase in June. This uptick, aligning with economists’ forecasts, suggests the economy is on firmer ground than previously thought. After adjusting for inflation, real consumer spending gained 0.4%, maintaining momentum from the second quarter. Conrad DeQuadros, senior economic advisor at Brean Capital, notes, “There is nothing here to push the Fed to a half-point cut. This is not the kind of spending growth associated with recession.”

While spending surged, inflation remained relatively contained. The Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, rose 0.2% for the month and 2.5% year-on-year. Core PCE inflation, which excludes volatile food and energy prices, increased by 0.2% monthly and 2.6% annually. These figures, while showing progress towards the Fed’s 2% target, indicate that inflationary pressures persist, potentially complicating the central bank’s decision-making process.

Despite a jump in the unemployment rate to a near three-year high of 4.3% in July, which initially stoked recession fears, the labor market continues to generate decent wage growth. Personal income rose 0.3% in July, with wages climbing at the same rate. This suggests that the slowdown in the labor market is primarily due to reduced hiring rather than increased layoffs.

Fed Chair Jerome Powell recently signaled that a rate cut was imminent, acknowledging concerns over the labor market. However, the strong consumer spending data may force the Fed to reconsider the pace and magnitude of potential rate cuts. David Alcaly, lead macroeconomic strategist at Lazard Asset Management, offers a longer-term perspective: “There’s a lot of focus right now on the pace of rate cuts in the short term, but we believe it ultimately will matter more how deep the rate-cutting cycle goes over time.”

The Atlanta Fed has raised its third-quarter GDP growth estimate to a 2.5% annualized rate, up from 2.0%. This revision, coupled with the strong consumer spending data, paints a picture of an economy that’s more resilient than many had anticipated. The increase in spending was broad-based, covering both goods and services. Consumers spent more on motor vehicles, housing and utilities, food and beverages, recreation services, and financial services. They also boosted spending on healthcare, visited restaurants and bars, and stayed at hotels.

As the Fed navigates this complex economic landscape, investors and policymakers alike will be closely watching for signs of whether the central bank will prioritize fighting inflation or supporting economic growth in its upcoming decisions. The robust consumer spending data suggests that the economy may not need as much support as previously thought, potentially leading to a more cautious approach to rate cuts.

For investors, this economic resilience presents both opportunities and challenges. While strong consumer spending bodes well for many sectors, it may also lead to a less accommodative monetary policy than some had hoped for. As always, a diversified approach and close attention to economic indicators will be crucial for navigating these uncertain waters.

Strong Business Spending and Government Demand Drive Upward Q3 GDP Revision

US economic output grew at a faster pace than initially estimated in the third quarter, according to revised GDP data released Wednesday by the Commerce Department. The upgraded third quarter growth paints a picture of resilient business and government spending offsetting slowing consumer demand.

GDP expanded at an annualized rate of 5.2% during the July to September period, topping the advance reading of 4.9% growth. Upward revisions were fueled primarily by fixed business investment and government expenditures proving stronger than expected.

Corporate Investments Defy Recession Fears
As rising rates threaten housing and construction, many economists feared companies would pull back on equipment investments amid an uncertain outlook. However, nonresidential fixed investment, encompassing structures, equipment, intellectual property and more, rose 1.3% in Q3.

While this marked a steep decline from 6.1% growth in Q2, business spending has moderated far less than feared. Companies seem focused on funding promising productivity enhancements even as they trim costs elsewhere. Tech and machinery upgrades that drive efficiency and cut costs over the long term remain attractive.

Surprisingly resilient corporate investment provided vital ballast for growth last quarter. Coupled with still-healthy consumer spending, albeit revised down slightly, business capital outlays appear sufficient to keep the US out of recession territory for now.

Government Spending Spikes
In addition to business investment, government expenditures at the federal, state and local levels increased 5.8% in Q3, meaningfully higher than early readings. Surging defense spending as well as state investments in education drove elevated government consumption.

With Democrats in control of Congress and the White House, pandemic-era support programs also continued stimulating significant public sector demand.

Consumer Engine Slows but Remains Solid
Although personal consumption spending fell short of initial 4% growth estimates and instead rose a still-strong 3.6%, households continue underpinning US growth. A super-tight jobs market, rising wages and abundant savings for higher-income Americans seem sufficient to maintain solid consumer demand.

However, with borrowing costs jumping and inflation eating away at incomes, an evident slowdown in spending ahead of the crucial holiday season presents economic risks. Any further erosion of consumption could spur layoffs and trigger recessionary conditions. For now at least, consumers appear positioned to continue carrying the torch.

Strong Growth But Uncertainty Lingers
Thanks to business and government resilience, Q3 expansion topped already lofty expectations. This provides a sturdy launching pad heading into year-end. But with the Fed aggressively tightening policy and key trading partners teetering on the brink of recession, clouds linger on the horizon. Another quarter of solid growth could be the high water mark before a challenging 2024.

From Inflation to Deflation: A Seasonal Shift in Consumer Prices

Consumers tapped out from inflation may finally get a reprieve this holiday season in the form of falling prices. According to Walmart CEO Doug McMillon, deflation could be on the horizon.

On a Thursday earnings call, McMillon said the retail giant expects to see deflationary trends emerge in the coming weeks and months. He pointed to general merchandise and key grocery items like eggs, chicken, and seafood that have already seen notable price decreases.

McMillon added that even stubbornly high prices for pantry staples are expected to start dropping soon. “In the U.S., we may be managing through a period of deflation in the months to come,” he said, welcoming the change as a benefit to financially strapped customers.

His comments echo optimism from other major retailers that inflation may have peaked. Earlier this week, Home Depot CFO Richard McPhail remarked that “the worst of the inflationary environment is behind us.”

Government data also hints the pricing pressures are easing. The consumer price index (CPI) for October was flat compared to September on a seasonally adjusted basis. Core CPI, which excludes volatile food and energy costs, dipped to a two-year low.

This emerging deflationary environment is a reprieve after over a year of runaway inflation that drove the cost of living to 40-year highs. Everything from groceries to household utilities saw dramatic price hikes that squeezed family budgets.

But the October CPI readings suggest the Federal Reserve’s aggressive interest rate hikes are having the desired effect of reining in excessive inflation. As supply chains normalize and consumer demand cools, prices are softening across many categories.

For instance, the American Farm Bureau Federation calculates that the average cost of a classic Thanksgiving dinner for 10 will be $64.05 this year – down 4.5% from 2022’s record high of $67.01. The drop is attributed largely to a decrease in turkey prices.

Still, consumers aren’t out of the woods yet when it comes to stubborn inflation on essentials. While prices are down from their peak, they remain elevated compared to historical norms.

Grocery prices at Walmart are up mid-single digits versus 2022, though up high-teens compared to 2019. Many other household basics like rent, medical care, and vehicle insurance continue to rise at above average rates.

And American shopping habits reflect the impact of lingering inflation. Walmart CFO John David Rainey noted consumers have waited for discounts before purchasing goods such as Black Friday deals.

McMillon indicated shoppers are still monitoring spending carefully. So while deflationary pressure is a tailwind, Walmart doesn’t expect an abrupt return to pre-pandemic spending patterns.

The retailer hopes to see food prices in particular come down faster, as grocery inflation eats up a significant chunk of household budgets. But experts warn it could take the rest of 2023 before inflation fully normalizes.

Consumers have been resilient yet cautious under economic uncertainty. If deflation takes root across the retail landscape, it could provide much-needed relief to wallets and mark a turning point toward recovery. For now, the environment looks favorable for a little more jingle in shoppers’ pockets this holiday season.