The Federal Reserve is expected to lower interest rates again this week, even as policymakers navigate an unusually uncertain environment caused by the ongoing government shutdown. With most official economic data unavailable since early October, central bank officials are relying on private-sector reports and anecdotal evidence to guide their decision-making.
This marks the second rate cut of 2025, as the Fed continues to balance the dual challenges of cooling inflation and a weakening job market. The shutdown, which began on October 1, has halted the release of key reports, including the monthly jobs data that typically plays a pivotal role in shaping monetary policy. In the absence of those figures, alternative data sources from payroll processors and research firms suggest that hiring has slowed sharply, pointing to potential cracks in the labor market.
Private-sector reports indicate that U.S. employers reduced jobs in September, marking a significant shift from the steady gains earlier in the year. Sectors like healthcare continue to add positions, but most other areas — including manufacturing, construction, and retail — are showing signs of contraction. Economists believe this slowdown reflects weaker demand rather than a shortage of available workers, signaling that the broader economy may be cooling more rapidly than anticipated.
Adding to the complexity, inflation data remains mixed. The Consumer Price Index showed a slight decline in September, with core inflation rising 3% year over year, down from 3.1% the month prior. While the moderation in prices provides some relief, inflation still sits above the Fed’s 2% target. Economists warn that new tariffs and rising consumer costs could keep price pressures elevated in the months ahead, making it harder for policymakers to strike the right balance.
The Fed’s dilemma is compounded by growing signs of financial strain in certain lending markets. Losses in subprime auto loans and stress in commercial lending have raised concerns about the overall health of the financial system. While analysts don’t view these issues as systemic, they consider them early indicators that consumers and smaller banks are under pressure as growth slows.
Despite these warning signs, most analysts expect the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) to approve a 0.25% rate cut this week, bringing borrowing costs further down as part of a broader effort to support the labor market. Markets have already priced in another possible cut before year’s end, though the timing and extent of future moves will likely depend on when official government data becomes available again.
Fed Chair Jerome Powell has acknowledged that the lack of reliable data leaves policymakers in a difficult position, forcing them to rely on partial information and economic models to assess risks. With inflation easing slightly but employment softening, the central bank appears committed to erring on the side of supporting growth — even if that means acting with limited visibility.
The path ahead remains uncertain. If inflation stabilizes and job losses accelerate, the Fed may continue cutting rates into early 2026. But if inflation proves more persistent than expected, the central bank could be forced to pause its easing cycle sooner than markets anticipate. Either way, the current data blackout underscores how fragile the economic landscape remains — and how challenging it is for the Fed to steer policy when flying blind.