Statistically, 2023 Should Finally Be the Year for Small Caps
It has been six months since I shared the hard data and a graphic from Royce Investment Partners. In the firms most recent letter to investors, the firm reiterated the reality that after any consecutive five-year period where small-cap stocks had returned less than five percent, the following year, returns averaged 14.9%. Senior management of Royce again stated in its July newsletter, that a five-year low-performing period occurred 81 times in history, 81 times small caps had a sixth year with very good returns.
Are Small Cap Stocks on Track to Make it 82 Times in a Row?
The five-year period 12/31/83 through 6/30/23, was below 5% for each year. January kicked off the sixth year return was up over 5%. Since the strong January, we have had a strong June, and so far July. Year-to-date, the Russell 2000 index is up 9.4%, which is a strong six months – with six months to go. If it stays on course, small caps will keep the “100% of the time history.”
What is even more exciting is that in the month of June alone, the small cap index was up 6.9% and so far in July is up on the month and outperforming large cap indexes, which are all down on the month.
While a 100% of the time track record is comforting, the idea that so far only months that start with the letter “J” have been up, and after this month, we run out of “J” months, is concerning. The Royce newsletter dated July 7th has pointed out another positive statistic for where we are now.
Co-CIO Francis Gannon recognized, “It’s true that January and June were the only months so far in 2023 when the Russel 2000 had positive returns. There were four straight down months in between.” Gannon explained that this is also a rare occurrence that has occurred only nine times since the start of the Russell 2000 on the last day of 1978. The Co-CIO said, “For the eight periods for which we have data, subsequent one-year returns averaged 24.7%; subsequent three-year returns averaged 21.0%; and subsequent five-year returns averaged 16.8%.”
These numbers work on a simple, buy-the-dip phenomenom, but quantify it in a way that gives investors confidence that at a minimum there is a rationale behind expanding holdings in small cap stocks.
Take Away
Investing, at it’s core, is putting statistics on your side, expecting that it is not different this time, then letting historical probabilities play out. Large cap stocks are expensive compared to small caps. This may not be the only reason the two scenarios discussed in newsletters from Royce Capital Partners have played out. But other factors, including a rebalancing of the Nasdaq 100 Index this summer, strongly favor a more competitive performance of small cap stocks in 2023 than we have experienced in five years.
Managing Editor, Channelchek
Sources